Domestic Discipline Before “I Do”

 Domestic Discipline Before “I Do”

When people hear that my husband and I practice domestic discipline in our marriage, they often assume it began after the wedding. The truth is, the foundation was laid much earlier—during our courting years in college—long before we ever shared a home or even held hands without intention.

While we were dating, my husband was very clear about his convictions. We did not live together. We did not sleep together. I was a virgin when we married, and our relationship was built deliberately, with boundaries that honored God and protected both of us. Because of that, he also believed that spanking had no place in our relationship before marriage. Even though I was already drawn to structure, leadership, and accountability, he felt physical discipline was reserved for the covenant of marriage.

That did not mean, however, that there was no discipline at all.

During our college years, when I misbehaved—missed curfew, spoke disrespectfully, procrastinated on responsibilities, or tested boundaries—he addressed it. Calmly. Firmly. Consistently. He believed that courting was not just about affection, but discernment. He wanted to know whether I could follow his lead, accept correction, and grow under guidance rather than resist it.

The consequences were practical and, at times, uncomfortable. I wrote lines—sometimes pages of them—reflecting on what I had done wrong and how I would do better. Early bedtimes were enforced, even when friends were out late. I was grounded from social events. Privileges were taken away. Extra chores were assigned, usually when I already felt overwhelmed with schoolwork.

And then there were the physical exercises.

Wall sits that made my legs shake. Planks that tested my resolve. Holding positions longer than I thought I could manage. These weren’t punishments meant to humiliate me; they were meant to teach self-control, endurance, and obedience. He watched closely—not with cruelty, but with intention. Would I complain? Would I quit? Or would I push through and trust that he knew what he was asking of me?

Looking back, I see that those moments were about far more than consequences. They were about character. He wasn’t just correcting behavior; he was discerning whether I was willing to submit to leadership with humility and grace. And I was learning something equally important—that structure didn’t diminish me, it steadied me.

By the time we married, domestic discipline didn’t feel foreign or shocking. It felt familiar. Safe. Earned. The trust had already been built, the roles already understood. Spanking, when it later became part of our marriage, rested on a foundation of years of proven leadership and willing followership.

Our courting years taught me that discipline is not about control for control’s sake. It is about love that is intentional, boundaries that protect, and growth that prepares you for covenant. I am deeply grateful that my husband honored me enough to wait—and wise enough to lead me even before we said our vows.


Comments

  1. Hmm. I find this article interesting, but this makes me reflect on myself, it definitely depends on the man, because I'm sure that if a man tried while I was dating tried to enforce such rules on me, I'd probably leave. What draws me to spanking is that it's a pretty efficient correction method, and extremely painful. So I won't be hours grounded, or have many privileges taken away.

    I guess it also depends on the woman!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi, Thank you so much for your feedback.
      I totally understand how my lifestyle is not for everybody. It's perfect for me and I thrive with boundaries and guidelines. I knew him in high school and I knew what I wanted in a husband. I would watch him in awe when he took charge, not just me but in life, left me weak in the knees. He was so level headed and I loved listening to him. He not only was smart he was wise and when he made choices he was so decisive. I also always had an out by my safe word, not only for punishments but anything. We would stop what we were doing and talk about it.
      I hope that clears up why I chose this man.

      Delete
  2. I wish the church addressed this and the way men and women are designed. You articulate it very well and I respect his restraint and creativity. As an athlete I know the pain of wall sits and planks, well done.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you sir for your feedback. I do work out, my husband is my personal trainer (he's free) and I run a lot.

      Delete
  3. As a newlywed this is so interesting to me Lisa! My husband and I had a short whirlwind courtship and engagement of only six months and we did discuss our convictions of submission and headship, we did not have an opportunity for any discipline leading up to our wedding. All of our courtship was chaperoned. We also refrained from most physical contact during courtship except for short hugs and closed mouth kisses.
    I did just two nights ago earn my first discipline session when I had some disrespectful attitude while we were eating dinner at my parents house. Praise God Seth did not spank me. I knelt in front of him while he lectured me about my misdeeds and reminded me that this is my warning as a new wife and the next time I will be spanked. Half of me wishes we had gotten a first spanking over with but the other half of me is grateful for his mercy.
    I do wonder if our courtship had been longer and we had more alone time if I would have gotten more "practice" with active submission and discipline.
    All Glory to God,
    Sage

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Sage, thank you so much for sharing so openly and thoughtfully. I really appreciate your honesty, especially as a newlywed finding your footing in marriage. It’s clear you and Seth took your courtship and convictions very seriously, and that foundation of intentionality and reverence comes through in what you wrote.

      I smiled at your reflection about “practice,” because I think many of us wonder how different things might have felt with more time or different circumstances. What I’ve learned, though, is that submission and discipline are not things we master ahead of time—they unfold within marriage itself, through grace, patience, and yes, sometimes mercy. Your husband’s choice to warn and instruct rather than spank speaks to his care and discernment as a new head of his household, and your mixed feelings make perfect sense.

      Marriage has a way of teaching us quickly, regardless of the length of courtship. You will grow into these roles together, step by step, and the learning continues long after the wedding day. Thank you again for your kind words and for adding such a meaningful perspective to the conversation. I pray your marriage continues to be guided by wisdom, humility, and love.

      Blessings to you both,
      Lisa

      Delete
    2. Thank you for your reply Lisa. I really like what you said about submission not being something to master ahead of time, but something that we will grow into. That really resonated with me as I am learning a brand new role in my life.
      One of the things Seth and I had agreed on during courtship was me wearing feminine and modest clothing once we are married, but I owned very few skirts and dresses. After I got my lecture a couple of nights ago, Seth said that we would go shopping and that as I wear more feminine clothes that may serve as a reminder to me daily of my submission to him. We actually had a really fun day out at several shops while I got several new skirts and some very pretty dresses for church. I still have to wear pants to work, but I am to wear my new modest wardrobe otherwise. (I work for a company that provides after school childcare at a local elementary school. Pants make more sense for my job. But I take community college classes in the day, so I will from now on wear my skirts at home and at community college, and change into pants for work.) I do hope that my skirts will remind me of the joys of femininity, and I do take comfort in the fact that my husband likes me in them.

      Delete
    3. Sage, thank you for sharing this follow-up. It’s really lovely to hear how thoughtfully you and Seth are navigating these early days of marriage together.

      I think you will find being in feminine clothes will help you get into the roll of submissive wife. How do you feel in those skirts? I know that I find it is easy to forget my place and weirdly forget that I am a woman. I don't know if that makes sense.

      I blush to tell you this next part, but when I am disciplined. Most of the time I am nude when he lectures me. It is hard to forget that I am a woman when I am standing nude in front of my husband as he reminds me of proper behavior of a young lady. As I stand there about to go over his knee.

      Thank you again for sharing so openly. I think many women, especially newly married ones, will find encouragement and reassurance in your reflections.

      Delete
    4. Lisa I am three days into wearing skirts (except for at work of course) and I find that I am liking it. Of course I am new to wearing skirts so I am very aware of my clothes in a way that I normally am not but probably in the future this will feel second nature to me.
      You don't have to blush about taking discipline in the nude. Based on my reading of Aaron's blog I assumed all disciplined wives were spanked and lectured nude. I was clothed for my recent lecture, and I don't know what Seth's plans are on that front in the future.

      Delete
    5. Sage, I love wearing skirt or dress at work. I am High School Teacher. Makes me feel good about myself. I blush about being spanked nude, because despite it being normal I put it out here and now the world will know. Thank you for your feedback.

      Delete
  4. I find it so interesting to learn about how other couples handle such things! Our experiences were very different. I married immediately out of high school just a couple of weeks after my eighteenth birthday. Like Sage above, all of our two-year courtship was completely chaperoned. Though I was submissive from the beginning, we did not practice spanking until a few years into our marriage. It was a scary but ultimately welcome addition to our marriage.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hey Darcy, Thank you for sharing. The guy I was interested in high school went off to college and with a promise to my dad I went to college at 17. So I did have 2 years also between leaving home and getting spanked. But it happened right after I married.

      I think it is always scary at the start.... actually I think it still gives me butterflies.

      This is very interesting that there are so many flavors of Husband led household.

      Delete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

About My Other Blog - Lisa’s Spanking Journal

Can anyone Tell?

Learning Grace and Accountability in Marriage